• Melissa L. Steinberg

Second Circuit Rules That Debt Dispute Need Not Be in Writing

Updated: Aug 29, 2019

The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) requires debt collectors to send their debtors written notice containing certain information, including the amount of the debt, the name of the creditor, and a statement informing debtors that they have thirty (30) days to dispute the validity of the debt, or the debt collector will assume that the debt is valid.  Debt collectors have long taken the position that any dispute as to the validity of a debt must be in writing.  The Third Circuit (Delaware, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and U.S. Virgin Islands) has agreed with this position; the Ninth Circuit (Alaska, Arizona, California, Guam, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Northern Mariana Islands, Oregon, and Washington) has taken the opposite view.

This may seem like the sort of thing that would not come before the courts very often, and for the most part, that has been the case.  Debt collectors and debtors alike usually assume that any sort of dispute must be in writing, as the FDCPA specifies that other disputes must be in writing to be effective.

It is this failure on the part of the FDCPA’s drafters, whether or not it was intentional, to specify whether debt disputes must be in writing that appears to have doomed the traditional viewpoint of the debt collection industry and the Third Circuit, at least here in the Second Circuit (Connecticut, New York, and Vermont).  The Second Circuit recently ruled that the FDCPA does not require debt disputes to be in writing, in part because the plain language of the FDCPA specifically does not include a writing requirement, and in part because the right to dispute a debt is so fundamental that even those individuals who are unable to write, or who can write only with great difficulty, should not be deprived of the opportunity to exercise such an important right.

#FairDebtCollectionPracticesAct #NinthCircuit #SecondCircuit #ThirdCircuit

8 views

DISCLAIMER: The material provided on this website (including linked websites and/or blogs) is for informational purposes only, and for the purposes of New York State rules governing attorney ethics, this site may be considered attorney advertising. The information provided herein is intended to be general in nature, is not intended to address the specific situation of any reader or third party, is not legal advice, does not replace the assistance, representation, or advice of qualified legal counsel, and does not constitute an attorney-client relationship between any party and the Law Office of Melissa L. Steinberg, PLLC or Melissa L. Steinberg, Esq.  Every effort has been made to ensure that the information contained herein is timely, up-to-date, and accurate. However, because this information is not tailored to the needs of any particular individual, and because the law is ever-changing, neither the Law Office of Melissa L. Steinberg, PLLC nor Melissa L. Steinberg, Esq. makes any claim as to the accuracy of information contained herein, nor does the Law Office of Melissa L. Steinberg, PLLC  and/or Melissa L. Steinberg, Esq. guarantee any particular outcome should any party undertake any action, or fail to undertake any action, based on the information contained herein.  

NOTICE OF COPYRIGHT: © Melissa L. Steinberg, Esq. and Law Office of Melissa L. Steinberg, PLLC, 2012-2019. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without permission from Melissa L. Steinberg, Esq. is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Melissa L. Steinberg, Esq. and/or Law Office of Melissa L. Steinberg, PLLC and/or Anti-Terror Lawyer's Toolkit, as appropriate, with clear and specific direction to the original content.

TERMS AND CONDITIONS: The complete Terms and Conditions for using this website, and any content contained herein, is available here. Any user of this website or the content contained herein is responsible for complying with these Terms and Conditions at all times, without exception.

PRIVACY POLICY: The Privacy Policy governing this website's collection and use of information is set forth here, as well as in other locations on this website to maximize user knowledge of and exposure to such Privacy Policy, which fulfills any obligation of this website to publish or disseminate such Privacy Policy.